The Doctor's Corner: Demystifying bioidentical hormones

July 18, 2012|By Jane Bening

Editor's note: This is the last in a three-part series on menopausal hormones.


Put simply, bioidentical is a marketing term, first introduced into contemporary parlance by celebrities endorsing products.

The medical community has embraced this hormone adjective of necessity, owing to its popular cachet. Bioidentical means that hormones, for example estrogen and progesterone, are chemically synthesized; yes, man-made from plant sources, such that they are identical to those produced naturally in our bodies. From there, the plot in this Byzantine field thickens.

For starters, there is much confusion about compounded or so called formulated hormones. These are mixed by hand in batches by formulating pharmacists from the same plant-derived hormones used by pharmaceutical companies to produce bioidentical hormone products.


An advisory panel of the North American Menopause Society (NAMS) does not recommend use of compounded hormone therapy unless patients are allergic to products approved by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration. Check out new guidelines at published in their journal Menopause, in March 2012. I have been a medical speaker for several drug companies that sell FDA-approved hormone therapy, because of the variety of bioidentical products and convenient dosing flexibility. These are tested for purity, potency, and efficacy, not always the case for compounded hormone therapy.

Compounded hormone mixtures may include estriol, and are sometimes injected under the skin in pellets. Experts do not recommend either of these practices because of inadequate information about safety and efficacy.

What's more, some physicians who prescribe compounded hormone therapy adjust doses based on saliva testing. The FDA concludes that this practice has no scientific basis. Instead, hormone therapy doses should be adjusted on symptom response, according to Dr. Holly Thacker, director of the Center for Specialized Women's Health at the renowned Cleveland Clinic, as published in an article on bioidentical hormone therapy in their Journal of Medicine last December. See more at and

Similarly, experts opine that blood levels of hormones often ordered by practitioners are of dubious clinical relevance. This practice most certainly can add significant expense.

Coastline Pilot Articles Coastline Pilot Articles